I agree with most of the purposal. But the only thing is that about the edit requirement. Why do we need them anyway? Some users have a user right, but they did not meet the requirement, especially the inactive ones.
This sounds great. The requirements are passable, but I'm not sure with the edit count requirement. Because there are users who are interested to watch out for detrimentals but does not interested to making a fanon.
I agree with it. However, as other users said, edit count does not necessary to put the requirement(because each edit may not have same quality I guess), so I think it would be better if the edit count is excluded on the requirements.